Bollywood going bold? Cheeni Kum Vs Nishabd

Bollywood has come a long way in the recent past and this can be ‘confirmed’ with the movies which are being released in the past few years. More and more directors are willing to take risks and break away from the standard formula of family dramas or melodrama with song sequences, comedy and villains. The success of movies such as Iqbal, Dil Chahta Hai, Munna Bhai, Rang De Basanti, Dhoom, Krish and others on the box office confirms that the appetite to experiment has increased in Bollywood over the years.

The release of movies such as Being Cyrus, Metro, Nishabd, Cheeni kum and others indicates that there is more in the offing. Two movies Nishabd and Cheeni Kum which were released in the recent past reiterate this fact. Although the movies deal with the subject of complicated love that sprouts at a later stage in an individual’s life, it is the treatment of the movies that draws a stark contrast between the two! A classic example of looking at a half filled glass, while Cheeni Kum would call it half filled, Nishabd would call it half empty!

Nishabd

Nishabd comes from RGV factory so it has a certain watermark such as a mute intensity, fascinating camera work and a slow pace quintessential for the sensitive subject of the movie. The cast include Amitabh Bachchan, Jiah Khan and Revathi in the lead roles. Ram Gopal Varma asks several questions through the movie such as-

What happens when a man falls in love in his later life? What are the ramifications of such a development?Can it happen?Is it acceptable within the institution and frame of our ‘society’?

The movie takes a more ‘realistic’ approach and treatment to the subject wherein the director presents the affection that mushrooms in Amitabh Bachchan’s character as ‘human’. He tries to unweave the notion of ‘love’ from the fabric of ‘age’ as is commonly perceived and accepted in our society. The movie puts for the idea that love is an instinctive phenomenon that is not governed by ‘age’ and could happen to a person at any point in time.

This emotional roller coaster is presented in the brief ‘romance’ that occurs between the charismatic Amitabh Bachchan and the ‘feral’ Jiya Khan. The subtleties of this ‘liaison’ are well captured by Ram Gopal Varma through flirtatious encounters between the two protagonists Bachchan and Khan.

The plot slowly unfolds the abnormal predicament that Vijay, a photographer in his later 50’s played by Amitabh Bachchan finds himself in as he is introduced to Jiah played by the sexy nymphet Jiah Khan through his daughter Ritu played by Shraddha Arya.

What begins with a caustic and witty introduction soon assumes overtures of adulation and attraction. Jiah shatters the desolate and quiet world of Vijay by her attitude, looks and a certain feral charm. In the process Vijay finds a queer but nice feeling that had evaded his married life to Amrita played by Revathy. Jiah brings to surface that part of Vijay that was lost and this ‘self-introduction’ draws him to her. Jiah with her looks and carefree attitude also arouses a sense of uncouth but pleasurable fulfillment in the sedate life of Vijay.

Vijay finds the norms of the society too strong to accommodate his affection and chooses to align with the unspoken dictum of the society that relegates such a feeling as insanity. However, the feeling is so strong that Vijay chooses to end his life as he finds the torment too strong to suffer from. The movie does not offer any solution to this strange feeling or predicament that individuals could find themselves in at a later stage in life, feelings which are unacceptable within the norms of the society.

The score is composed by Vishal who composed the music for the memorable song ‘Rozaana Jiye’ in the movie. The song and the background score sets the tune for a certain ‘dreariness’ that lingers along in the movie and accentuates it to a great extent!

Another superb performance by Amitabh Bachchan who once again proved why he is the ‘Big B’ of Bollywood. He carried the weight of the role solely on his shoulders and brought out the agony and ecstasy of ‘Vijay’ in an emphatic manner with great elan. Jiya Khan too gave a laudable performance and Ram Gopal Varma needless to say brought out the best from his actor and actress in the movie.

Cheeni Kum

As mentioned above, Cheeni Kum presents a different perspective to a similar predicament although in a lighter vein! Interestingly, the protagonist in both the movie happens to be Amitabh Bachchan, although the treatment of the subject is very different in both the films.

In Cheeni Kum, Amitabh Bachchan plays the role of a 64 year old chef, Budhdhadev Gupta who is single and owns a restaurant in London. He is well known for his obsession with perfection as far as cooking goes, short temper and ego. The movie shows how love fosters between him and 34 year old Neena Verma played by Tabu and the complexities involved in Budhha seeking Neena’s hand for marriage from Paresh Rawal who plays her father in the movie.

The movie looks at love and relationship between two individuals despite a big difference in age between them. This rather complicated situation is looked at in a rather practical and lighter vein in the movie. The narrative of the movie also shows a divide in the thought process which bears the hallmark of generation gap at some level too! This is well portrayed in the mind set of the characters of Paresh Rawal that reflects this ideology!

The director through the conversations that ensue between Bachchan and Paresh Rawal brings out the rift or divide which at some level also reveals the different ways to look at age and relationship in the East and West. Paresh Rawal’s attitude at some level reflects the mindset of the multitude in our society where the later half of the life is relegated to self discipline and surrender to the almighty, in other words- withdrawal from different spheres of activity. This is what springs as a bone of contention when relationship and love at a later stage surfaces. Age according to Paresh Rawal becomes a deterrent and individuals have certain eddies like senior citizen status etc to confine themselves to.

The background score and tracks in the movie are composed by the great Illayaraja music and for a change the tracks have a certain melody bereft of the clamor of high pitch singing or shrieking sounds.

‘Horizon is as far as the vision can stretch’ – this is the idea the movie tries to put forth wherein aging is dubbed as a psychological phenomenon and limitations, boundaries and definitions are psychological constructs erected by society.